Wow... I seriously cannot choose. Deadly's list contains the greatest publically known female wrestlers and Dr. Death's contain the best of the best.

Originally Posted by Sahu

Both the lists lack something...in Rick's list there is no The Rock n Dr.Death's list there is no SCSA...

So I go with Dr.Death...

totally agree, but ill go Dr death because like him or hate him you have to have the Rock, if he has nothing else he owns the mic

Gotta give it to Dr. Death, although the lack of Austin is unfortunate. However, Piper and Rock better than Jake and Trips (although I would put the Snake in a top 10).

Very close. I'd complain that it's supposed to be all inclusive, but there's only WWE people here.. but honestly I can't think of any TNA/WCW people that beat these out... I would put Bully Ray and Sting on a top 10 list though. To give Dr. Death his criteria due, neither have been as consistent as I'd like, so fair nuff.

Both great bloggers, both good lists.

Dr Death gets my vote.

I'm torn... How do you not include the Rock? However I'm not crazy about Flair being number one. Starr's one saving grace is Jake Roberts, but Death trumps him with Piper. Death for the win by way of the Rock.

Both guys left out some big names but to leave Flair and Rock out, I find very surprising. So for that I'm going with Dr. Death.

Rick Starr.