Both great lists but my vote goes to The_Crippler because he had the smackdown MITB match on his which was one of my favourites this year.

E:4
C:4

so far...

ELNIOJR easily.

His list even lists Superstar matches which at times had better matches then Raw. Good to see Christian vs. Orton is 3rd on both lists since this is correct so can't argue with both of there top 3. But ELNIOJRs 4th and 5th own Cripples 4th and 5th.

So ELNIOJR

Even though Crippler used the Punk vs Ziggler match which was awesome, I'd have to give it to ELNIOJR because of the six-man match which was awesome as well, but the stars in that match needed to be recognized.

In my mind, I like both Top 5 matches.
But for me it comes down to The 6 man tag team match Vs DZ vs CM Punk.

But I think my vote will go to the champ, The_Crippler

1-2-3 are same for both n also I wud have mentioned same top 3..

I like the fact that Crippler gave credit to Punk/Ziggler match...

But, I liked the Power to ppl match a lot...n also, I loved the fact that ELNIOJR gave credit to 6 ppl whom even i like most..USOs, Baretta, Slater/Gabriel n Tyson Kidd...

So, my vote goes to ELNIOJR...

My vote goes to the Crippler