I think it's very unfair, that Playboy Stevie had sooo many people on his list. Bearkg88, I know you said only take into a count his Top 5 guys, but i'm sure theirs many people who like a lot of people in his list who are not in his Top 5.
This is just very ridiculous, but even tho Playboy Stevie broke the rules, I still prefer his Top 5 list, than Tommy Thunder. My vote goes to Playboy Stevie.

how about Benoit vs Punk, or Benoit vs Bryan?

just one little correction to Playboy Stevie the reason demolition and lod did not feud for long is because fans looked out for it for quite a while but ax got a cuddlefish allergy so he couldn't wrestle for that period they brought in crush and it just wasn't what it should have been it wasn't ax and smash vs lod and that's why the feud was cut short the fans did not really like it as much as they could have too bad ax got a cuddlefish allergy

Just to address Playboy Stevie's comments, the feeling's mutual man. I know that you're a hardcore wrestling fan (I think I recall reading that you'd been watching since the 70's?), so I can also relay that I have a lot of respect for you man!

I admit that I didn't put as much thought as I'd have liked into this, but anyone who says that the feuds I picked aren't feuds they'd like to see are kidding themselves frankly. May be they aren't The top 5, but they're certainly top feuds that would be brilliant.
I think DK Wrestling Saviour's comments were very harsh on me. I respect your opinion, and if you don't think Dolph Ziggler and Daniel Bryan are good wrestlers then that's fine, but to call my top 5 list a "first 5 to come to mind" top 5 isn't exactly respectful.

Anyway, I've had a good time doing this, and I hope to get another chance sometime! But if I were reading this blog I'd also vote for Playboy, and I'd be a bit embarassed to beat him due to his superior knowledge, so I think he deserves to go through!

The Playboy's list - for being more realistic, accurate, meaningful and simple. And his Top 5 list got my attention specially his # 1. Plus, he understand how people think and vote, he gets into reader's mind (but sometimes majority doesn't mean they're right -- just present what you think is best and of course, the truth). Lastly, he obviously has the knowledge with the subject...

gotta go with the playboy The Rock v HBK, Taker v Sting, and Angle v Bret would be in my top 5 as well...I did like Tommy's Angle v Bryan feud tho that would be great.

Very good topic. I felt Tommy Thunder came up way way short though. Too many names from today involved. Dolph Ziggler? Really? Cody Rhodes vs Goldust? Daniel Bryan vs anybody? This is supposed to be TOP 5...not, first 5 that you can think of. I felt he put very little thought into this.

Playboy Stevie V gets my vote.