I'd say the top is better but it's like saying one turd smells better than another.
All kidding aside yours seems like it was made by a 4 year old.
Ok, I think I have a bead on your style now and I gotta say
tone it down a bit, you don't need 50 pictures and all the shirts/catchphrases of each wrestler whenever you make a wallpaper.
As a matter of fact, the best wrestling wallpapers I have seen have always been the simple ones, there is a great beauty in simplicity.
other than that, why not just make 1 thread for all of your wallpapers?
Good lord the top 1!
You cramped way to much stuff into yours.
Constructive criticism time - When it comes to posters believe me when i say less is more...look at the poster for the Godfather one of the best and most recognisable posters of all time and all it consist of are a hand and voodo string thingy. It looks like these posters were made by some 12 years. sorry
Saying that, iv just looked at the pics again and i have to say the bottom one is quite good, i like how you layed out the pics according to the setting so well done on the concept and layout