Pick a wrestler, and give him the most ridiculous gimmick you can think of that might actually work.
For example:
Kofi Kingston- Ghana African Cartel Leader, after winning a match Kofi leaves a mark on the opponent he beat something like a card or cigar or something. He has also has henchman that he uses to attack people and do his dirty work.
Now you guys pick a wrestler and give him a random gimmick that may actually work.

