Try the fish. ;)
I don't see the win for the WWE. Sure, they can claim that they have "gay" wrestlers on their show, but it would still be in question as to the authenticity of their "gayness" as it is scripted programming. What you are looking for would best be suited for a wrestler to come out in public forum as authentically being homosexual. Even at this point, the likelihood of it taking place would most likely occur after said athlete's career; coming out during their career could be damaging for the probability of being cornered into a specific role that couldn't be broken from. I'm pretty sure Chris Kanyon had this same problem which is what he claimed to help segregate him from the populous of the WWE locker room. Once it was known that he was into men, it seems as if his downward spiral leading to his tragic suicide began acceleration into his life’s final plunge.
Sure, I can see what you are saying in theory, but I don't think that "faking gay" on a television show known for its outrageous storylines would give the desired result you are looking for.
I don't want to see a "gay storyline" because 1) I can't stand relationship storylines in wrestling (the whole thing with AJ has just been icky) and 2) I'd much rather see an openly gay but not allowing it to drive his existence wrestler. Orlando Jordan in TNA annoyed me because his entire personality boiled down to "Look at me I like cock!" (something I can't stand equally in "Look at me I like vagina!" types) and it gets boring really quickly. I do think there's a lot of potential in addressing homosexuality as part of wrestling but most of what I can think of is Chuck and Billy or Mickie and Trish type stuff, none of which is particularly positive.
You want a homosexual wrestler? Have you not heard of John Cena?
Being Gay Doesn't Mean You can't watch wrestling, It just means we enjoy watching it more:p
That's not creepy at all. No i don't think it will ever happen, but if it does it would have to be someone that's gay in real life.
No chance of this happening anytime soon.
For starters, do you really think that Vince would be able to contain himself in doing this? No. He'd go over the top and make it a joke.
That leads to my second point; this gimmick/storyline would be nothing more than a comedy thing in WWE. I can't see Vince putting this in a legit serious main event storyline.
Also, I don't know of any mainstream openly gay wrestlers. Orlando Jordan is the biggest star that I know of who's openly come out as bisexual, other than that, I don't know of any. And I think for this kind of storyline/gimmick, the people involved would have to be gay themselves.