Well you have kinda have half missed what i was saying. I do agree it is funny at times but the reason i just think its ok is because 1, 2 and 3 are almost identical in alot of ways.
The humor and voice cast is the best thing about the Fable series and does make it very unique in that way. But from a gameplay perspective it hasnt progressed since its orginal Xbox run.
The Gnomes and Gargoyles arent very funny and its the same joke every game with them.
I honestly dont see the replay value in Fable 2 or 3 but it is very rare i replay a game several times that isnt a Bioware game.
You have to atleast admit they need to improve the gameplay and style of the game as they are very samey.