Has this ever happened before

[Androo]

This has TNA written all over it.

Or, you mean something similar to the absurdity presented in the "No.1 Contenders Contract On A Pole Match", between Ziggles and Del Rio, that occurred in on Raw a week or two ago?

BADOING!

[Los Conquistador]

TLC 2010
Ziggler vs Kofi vs Swagger for the intercontinental title

kofi and swagger both pulled down the title but ziggler grabbed it so he won
but apparently that was a botch and ziggler was supposed to catch the title before it hit the canvas

but yeah
only one winner i think