Who is the most over-rated/under-rated TNA wrestler/superstar?

[Poot-Hair]

Overrated- I would go with Jeff Hardy. He's decent at best but mostly a spot monkey who sells merch to all the little kiddie "creatures"

Underrated- I'd go with Eric Young. The guy is built like a brick shit house, has charisma oozing from every pore, and makes the best out of every gimmick he's given.

[thedag]

overrated - Aj he is a spot monkey and 75% wrestlers can do all his most. most can do them better.

ummm under rated umm = eric young.

[akbar]

Overrated - JBL, Edge, Kurt Angle, RVD, MVP(by the IWC)

Edit: My bad, didn't see this is just for TNA.

[HCollins-TNA1]

Over-rated.... Devon....
Sure he the TV Champion, sure he have beat all in his way..... But he hasn't really been challenged to best of his ability....

Under-rated.... Tie.. Eric Young, and Magnus....
Sure they both have been multi time tag champs and held various others titles... But they just seem held back at times... Magnus has a lot going for him with the BFG series... Hopefully if he don't win maybe TV title for him??? Eric Young the same almost can be said, with his outside ventures from wrestling with a show on Animal Planet... Think he would make a excellent annoucer or interviewer if they would add him to a spot like that..

[FXK2I]

Overrated: Hulk Hogan

Underrated: Brooke Hogan / Bully Ray

[Sahu]

Over Rated: Anderson (I never liked him), Angle/Sting ( past their prime), Crimson, Hernandez...
Under Rated: Kaz, Magnus, Pope, Eric Young ( a very talented guy..more talented than half of their roster yet very very under used)

I feel Daniels is not over rated...he's just hung up in a bad story line...n I really wonder some are saying AJ is over rated..I feel like what ever praises he's getting is less when compared to his talent...

Also, Roode is not over rated..but, I love Storm more than Roode...

[Sage]

Over rated- I'd have to say AJ styles. It's not that he isn't great but for years I'd heard people talk about him as if he were a flawless god of wrestling, than I finally saw tna he just didn't live up to the hype.

Under rated- I don't watch enough tna anymore to name somebody

[JohnnyV123]

It's not really fair to say a guys like Sting or Kurt Angle are overrated. It's like saying Undertaker is overrated because he only wrestles one match a year. Guys like them have gotten to a point where their greatness is judged on their past greatness not their current ability.

So as far as overrated I would say.....Mr. Anderson. Been said before fun on the mic but his moveset isn't really entertaining.

Underrated...there's a lot. The Pope lost his push because of heat in the back, Magnus has really impressed me lately but I wish he would add something to his look, EY is great would like to see him get beyond the comedy stuff at some point, Bully Ray is the best heel they have but he rarely wins a match, Abyss/Joseph Park is excellent in both roles but I don't feel gets the credit he deserves, and even Samoa Joe who gets a lot of credit should be THE guy in TNA not just one of the many so he is underrated.

[Rick BoA]

You see one RVD match you've seen 'em all.

Bully Ray has grown on me as a singles wrestler from what ive seen. I never thought the Dudleys could do well on their own.

[Robstar]

It's not really fair to say a guys like Sting or Kurt Angle are overrated. It's like saying Undertaker is overrated because he only wrestles one match a year. Guys like them have gotten to a point where their greatness is judged on their past greatness not their current ability.

So as far as overrated I would say.....Mr. Anderson. Been said before fun on the mic but his moveset isn't really entertaining.

Underrated...there's a lot. The Pope lost his push because of heat in the back, Magnus has really impressed me lately but I wish he would add something to his look, EY is great would like to see him get beyond the comedy stuff at some point, Bully Ray is the best heel they have but he rarely wins a match, Abyss/Joseph Park is excellent in both roles but I don't feel gets the credit he deserves, and even Samoa Joe who gets a lot of credit should be THE guy in TNA not just one of the many so he is underrated.

So, you're saying old wrestlers should get by on past glories alone then? Hogan is ok then? He gets a free pass because he headlined the first 3 Wrestlemanias? I don't think so.