The EWN Grand Prix Discussion Thread

**bearkg88** · 12-29-2012, 12:53 PM

Best Match: Pamich vs Eclipse
Best Promo: Hmm....I'm going with Eclipse/Edwards
Any Matches and/or Promos That Could've Been Improved: None that stuck out to me.
Any Other Positives: It was a good show, and good to see Pamich get the big win. I was expecting a Pamich vs Edwards main event.
Any Other Constructive Criticism: None really. Keep up the great job!

**No_1eddiefan** · 12-29-2012, 12:55 PM

Best Match: Eclipse vs. Pamich
Best Promo: Divine
Any Matches and/or Promos That Could've Been Improved: None that I could see. All promos were great and all were brilliant.
Any Other Positives: Nice to see Pamich get the win, although I felt Eclipse deserved it more. Pamich/Eclipse was the right final
Any Other Constructive Criticism: None that I could see.
Overall Show Grade: B+. Solid show.

**magglis** · 12-29-2012, 12:57 PM

Originally Posted by No_1eddiefan

Best Match: Eclipse vs. Pamich
Best Promo: Divine
Any Matches and/or Promos That Could've Been Improved: None that I could see. All promos were great and all were brilliant.
Any Other Positives: Nice to see Pamich get the win, although I felt Eclipse deserved it more. Pamich/Eclipse was the right final
Any Other Constructive Criticism: None that I could see.
Overall Show Grade: B+. Solid show.

Yeah i do think bear stole the show with his promo

**TTC** · 12-29-2012, 01:12 PM

Feedback as following if you please:

Best Match: Eclipse/Pamich
Best Promo: Divine
Any Matches and/or Promos That Could've Been Improved: Nothing really.
Any Other Positives: N/A
Any Other Constructive Criticism: Actually I do have some. I would have had Divine kept silence, but I can see the positive side of it anyways. It already gives both men a starting point. My second problem is that the finals should have been Brock/Pamich. I love R(ob), but I don't think he was the right choice in my own personal opinion. He barely ICed, but I won't take anything away from his promo skills. However, you did said you took ICing into consideration, but I feel you really didn't. It's not sour grapes, because I was hoping for a Isarel win more than any else. However, I feel like ICing builds up a feud or match and that's what Brock and Isarel did. The two were the ones that were truly hyping up the event more than anyone and that to meant it should have been the two. I know you have your reasons man, but I got to disagree with the decision. It just didn't feel right with the main event. Don't take it personally, because the main event was awesome. It's just that Isarel/Edwards to me was the right way to go.
Overall Show Grade: B+

**bearkg88** · 12-29-2012, 01:16 PM

Originally Posted by TTC

Feedback as following if you please:

Best Match: Eclipse/Pamich
Best Promo: Divine
Any Matches and/or Promos That Could've Been Improved: Nothing really.
Any Other Positives: N/A
Any Other Constructive Criticism: Actually I do have some. I would have had Divine kept silence, but I can see the positive side of it anyways. It already gives both men a starting point. My second problem is that the finals should have been Brock/Pamich. I love R(ob), but I don't think he was the right choice in my own personal opinion. He barely ICed, but I won't take anything away from his promo skills. However, you did said you took ICing into consideration, but I feel you really didn't. It's not sour grapes, because I was hoping for a Isarel win more than any else. However, I feel like ICing builds up a feud or match and that's what Brock and Isarel did. The two were the ones that were truly hyping up the event more than anyone and that to meant it should have been the two. I know you have your reasons man, but I got to disagree with the decision. It just didn't feel right with the main event. Don't take it personally, because the main event was awesome. It's just that Isarel/Edwards to me was the right way to go.
Overall Show Grade: B+

The bolded statement. When Maggs made the comment he already chose the final two for the match, and he was basing it off of promos and ic work, I was surprise to see it was Rob seeing as how he didn't nearly as much as TTC did.

**magglis** · 12-29-2012, 01:26 PM

Originally Posted by TTC

Feedback as following if you please:

Best Match: Eclipse/Pamich
Best Promo: Divine
Any Matches and/or Promos That Could've Been Improved: Nothing really.
Any Other Positives: N/A
Any Other Constructive Criticism: Actually I do have some. I would have had Divine kept silence, but I can see the positive side of it anyways. It already gives both men a starting point. My second problem is that the finals should have been Brock/Pamich. I love R(ob), but I don't think he was the right choice in my own personal opinion. He barely ICed, but I won't take anything away from his promo skills. However, you did said you took ICing into consideration, but I feel you really didn't. It's not sour grapes, because I was hoping for a Isarel win more than any else. However, I feel like ICing builds up a feud or match and that's what Brock and Isarel did. The two were the ones that were truly hyping up the event more than anyone and that to meant it should have been the two. I know you have your reasons man, but I got to disagree with the decision. It just didn't feel right with the main event. Don't take it personally, because the main event was awesome. It's just that Isarel/Edwards to me was the right way to go.
Overall Show Grade: B+

I was having a hard time to decide between you and R(ob) but i think i took the right choice.Also i do take ic posts into consideration
but the 90% of the results comes from the promos.Also i have to say that I've seen massive improvement from you

**thejman93** · 12-29-2012, 01:28 PM

Divine steals whatever show he's on, man. That promo was fucking golden.

**TTC** · 12-29-2012, 01:30 PM

Originally Posted by magglis

I was having a hard time to decide between you and R(ob) but i think i took the right choice.Also i do take ic posts into consideration
but the 90% of the results comes from the promos.Also i have to say that I've seen massive improvement from you

Thanks man. I just still fill effy on it, but I'm still glad Isarel was the one to win the thing. However, for future reference, you should probably take both IC and promos in a 50/50 manner.

**bearkg88** · 12-29-2012, 01:35 PM

Originally Posted by TTC

Thanks man. I just still fill effy on it, but I'm still glad Isarel was the one to win the thing. However, for future reference, you should probably take both IC and promos in a 50/50 manner.

In my eyes when I pick who to push and who note to, its 60% promo/40% icing, mainly because yes ICing can help progress a feud, and it keeps a thread active, but think to all of the huge moments, people turning heel, surprise debuts, shocking moments, they are all done within a promo and built up through a promo so to me, promo's have a little more weight.

**TTC** · 12-29-2012, 01:37 PM

Originally Posted by bearkg88

In my eyes when I pick who to push and who note to, its 60% promo/40% icing, mainly because yes ICing can help progress a feud, and it keeps a thread active, but think to all of the huge moments, people turning heel, surprise debuts, shocking moments, they are all done within a promo and built up through a promo so to me, promo's have a little more weight.

Yeah I see what you are saying. And I can agree to it.