Originally Posted by Dennis
I was way more than just underwhelmed in regards to If Not Now, When?, as I thought, save a song or two, the album flat out sucked. Shame, too, as I thought Light Grenades found the band really evolving and striking a balance between not completely betraying their earlier sound while also genuinely maturing as song-writers.
That said, while I think they've written a bunch of great songs, I don't think Incubus have ever crafted a truly
great album. Have they made really good albums with lots of terrific tunes? Sure. But the ever-elusive masterpiece record? Nah. Not even close.