Figured this would be a good ongoing topic, especially if it gets few good laughs. In your opinions, what are some past WWE gimmicks that you felt could have actually been good for the company if WWE utilized it better?
Since I'm going first, I'll choose Paul Burchill's Pirate Gimmick:
This one gave me a lot of laughs when I first saw the debut. It was fun, it fit with the times since pirates was extremely popular, courtesy of the Pirates of the Carribean craze, and the guy performing the role was a very good wrestler. It had a ton of potential to do all kinds of backstage, wacky, antiques. Too bad WWE let it die out. I think kids nowadays would love such a gimmick.