WWE.com posted an article naming AJ Lee and Paul Heyman as the "Best Actress" and "Best Actor" in the WWE. Tony Dawson commented on Heyman's win, saying, "Paul Heyman is to WWE what Marlon Brando was to Hollywood. He is the standard by which all others are measured. I will never forget his exchange with Mr. McMahon when he confessed to lying every single day to make it in this business. It was raw, powerful and absolutely brilliant."

Joey Styles added, "If taking liberties with the truth — such as him not having a business relationship with Brad Maddox and The Shield — is considered acting, then Paul is indeed WWE's best actor and I hope he gets the opportunity to give an acceptance speech because he has more microphone mastery than anyone else in WWE today."

AJ commented on her win, saying, "I didn't even know I was nominated," she told WWE.com. "Is there some sort of reward that goes along with this, like a Slammy? I already have two Slammys and I could add it to …"