- OVW Southern Tag Team Championship (2 times) – with Alex Silva
- TNA Gut Check winner
He is known for his work in Total Nonstop Action Wrestling under his real name, where he is a former TNA Gut Check winner. In addition, he competed in TNA’s then-developmental territory, Ohio Valley Wrestling, where he was a two time Southern Tag Team Champion.
Shaw is perhaps best known for his time in WWE, where he performed on the NXT brand under the ring name Dexter Lumis. He was a former member of The Way.
Notable Matches: vs. Mr Anderson at Lockdown 2014
Notable Feuds: vs. Mr Anderson, vs. Cameron Grimes
Other Notable Achievements: FTPW Championship, TNT Championship, USWA Championship, Vintage Heavyweight Championship (3 times)