- WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship – with Peyton Royce
- Impact Knockouts Tag Team Championship – with Cassie Lee
- PWWA Championship (2 times)
She is best known for her time in WWE, where she performed under the ring name Billie Kay. She is also known for her time in Impact Wrestling, where she competed as Jessie McKay.
In June 2007, Kay made her professional wrestling debut at Pro Wrestling Alliance (PWA) and she debuted one-year later for the Pro Wrestling Women’s Alliance promotion, where she became a two-time PWWA Champion. She later started competing on the independent circuit for multiple promotions in the United States for several years, most notably and commonly for Shimmer Women Athletes.
Notable Feuds: /w Peyton Royce vs. Liv Morgan, Asuka, Ember Moon